John Locke and personal identity: an impasse concerning justice
نویسندگان
چکیده
In the chapter "Of Identity and Diversity" of An Essay Concerning Human Understanding, Locke claims that justice is based on personal identity consciousness. However, this view leads to an impasse when defendant alleges he has no consciousness crime and, therefore, does not identify himself as person who committed crime: if it possible determine one crime, can we say punishment just? This article seeks (i) analyse exploring (a) its conceptual framework (b) development in letters Molyneux exchanged order (ii) elaborate a criticism Locke’s answer it. Compared secondary bibliography, which objection well established, originality consists elaborating new distinction between first third perspectives showing that, questioned by Molyneux, failed discuss issue necessary give adequate impasse. Keywords: Locke, identity, justice.
منابع مشابه
Locke on Consciousness, Personal Identity and the Idea of Duration
It is as undeniable as it is unhelpful to say that for Locke personal identity consists in the identity of consciousness. It is undeniable because he just comes out and says as much in passages like the following: “[T]he same consciousness being preserv’d. . .the personal Identity is preserv’d.” (II.xxvii.13)1 It is unhelpful, however, for two reasons: First, it is unclear what consciousness is...
متن کاملJohn Locke on Respiration
During the early part of his career as an academic in 1660s Oxford, John Locke trained as a physician. Acquainted with some of the most brilliant researchers of his day— Robert Boyle, Thomas Willis, Richard Lower and Robert Hooke—and an active member of the scientific community, Locke was part of a generation that revolutionized natural philosophy. He never published a natural philosophical wor...
متن کاملJohn Locke on Respiration JONATHAN WALMSLEY
During the early part of his career as an academic in 1660s Oxford, John Locke trained as a physician. Acquainted with some of the most brilliant researchers of his day— Robert Boyle, Thomas Willis, Richard Lower and Robert Hooke—and an active member of the scientific community, Locke was part of a generation that revolutionized natural philosophy. He never published a natural philosophical wor...
متن کاملChapter 15 John Locke : Theory of knowledge
In the previous chapter we have outlined some fundamental doctrines of Locke’s empiricism. We have examined his concepts of simple and complex ideas which are the archetypes of knowledge according to empiricist epistemology. The ideas of substances, modes and relations are the three types of complex ideas our mind forms by combining the simple ideas received from multiple sources. Before we pro...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
ژورنال
عنوان ژورنال: Filosofia Unisinos
سال: 2022
ISSN: ['1519-5023', '1984-8234']
DOI: https://doi.org/10.4013/fsu.2022.233.06